Know This
Feb 10, 2010
The other night I went to the world’s worst hip hop show. I need to believe it was the worst, though it likely wasn’t, because if this city can do worse than this, I’m giving up on all hope right here and right now.
I’m not going to get into how fucked it is for a hip hop show to consist of white boys in dreadlocks rapping to an almost exclusively white audience (including one guy in a do-rag), because others have written about that phenomenon more intelligently and less crassly than I could. But there were some details specific to the show that I’d like to believe were unique.
One of the rappers wore a fur tail (fake, I’m hoping) pinned to his bottom; he never explained why. He and his partner performed a song about how they got his sister off pads and onto menstrual cups; he used the word “temple” at one point, but I can’t remember the exact reference because I’m mostly suppressing the memory.
During the intermission the MC said, “I don’t know why anarchists haven’t taken over hip hop,” which made me swallow my drink the wrong way, setting my trachea on fire. I nearly hacked to death.
Perhaps less surprising (given the show was billed to an activist community), but no less gagworthy, was when the rappers called on their soundcheck person to do an impromptu performance — only because she was female. That kind of unselfconscious tokenism around gender dovetails beautifully with how resistance in hip hop music and cultures gets co-opted by white anarchists who think screeching “Fuck the system!” ten times makes for an acceptable hook.
There’s a lot of discussion around the larger phenomenon of young white men co-opting rap and adopting its assumed culture (no matter that that stereotype gets constantly teased by current mainstream black musicians), but there’s something more specific to how white activists co-opt these things. My sense is that their self-identification as “activists” is precisely the mechanism by which they allow themselves to be this ludicrously oblivious to the racial politics that they’re fooling around with. In other words, the problems of entitlement and self-awareness not only do not become less pressing within activist and/or anarchist communities, but in fact are re-entrenched through this notion that by being activist we’re all necessarily beyond this kind of petty squabbling over the ever-fraught intersections of art and history.
So it’s nice to come home to songs and videos like The Remnant’s “Know This“. The lyrics are cheesy as hell (will boys ever, ever get off the woman-as-muse hack), but the boys are pretty and have style, and the filming is so cute (I wish I’d filmed it). And, for the P&P aficionados among you, there’s a Jane Austen reference in there (or so he says, someone else run a check).

I want to get old, grow a gut that I suck in when I’m next to you. Sixty odd years old and still trying to impress you.
6 Responses to “Know This”
1 adnan. Feb 10, 2010
will boys ever, ever get off the woman-as-muse hack
no.
2 Jeff Feb 10, 2010
The guy with the tail pinned to his bottom: furry fan, I’m willing to wager.
And wondering if boys will ever get off the woman-as-muse hack to me is the same as wondering if humans will ever stop falling in love.
3 fathima Feb 10, 2010
sigh. well if men must insist on reducing women to passive conduits for their creative drives, you’d think they’d at least do better than “you are my sunshine.”
but seriously though, my problem is less with how ubiquitous the cliche is, than how fixed the gender roles are — women flattening their male lovers out into 2D characters for the purposes of creating art is somehow not as mainstream a trope. i can’t think why.
jeff, that wiki link taught me a lot of words ending with philia. yay.
4 adnan. Feb 11, 2010
hmmm… first of all, who said muses (is that a word? feels like the plural should be mice) have to be passive? i prefer critically engaged muses/mice.
“women flattening their male lovers out into 2D characters for the purposes of creating art is somehow not as mainstream a trope”
perhaps when women entered the public creative realm, they decided they could be much better. (this might not be a true story, i just made it up. but it could be plausible). you know, “let’s not up the gender that’s suppressed us all this time” kinda thing.
5 fathima Feb 11, 2010
right, i’m not advocating for gender parity in cheese
6 run like the wind » Solidarity Feb 13, 2010
[...] was a little unfair to anarchists in my previous post — though cultural and racial appropriation by white people of minority histories troubles me, [...]